Saudi Arabia frames its current military intervention into Yemen, which has involved wave upon wave of airstrikes for the past two weeks, as a bid to bring stability to a failing, unraveling state.
The country’s impotent Saudi-backed president, Abed Rabbo Mansour Hadi, was forced to flee the southern city of Aden after being cornered by Houthi rebels. The Houthis had seized the capital Sanaa last autumn as a part of a slow-moving takeover of parts of the country. A mess of competing factions, including al-Qaeda, were now warring over whole stretches of Yemen. The Saudi-led campaign, Saudi officials insisted, would turn back the Houthi advance and restore Hadi’s “legitimate” government to power.
But another narrative also came immediately into play — that of a Sunni-Shiite proxy war between Saudi interests in Yemen and the Iran-backed Houthis, who belong to a Shiite sect patronized by Tehran’s theocratic leadership.
[Read: How the Yemen conflict risks new chaos in the Middle East]
Hadi denounced the Houthis as “Iran’s puppet” at a March 29 meeting of the Arab League in Egypt where the Saudis enlisted a largely Sunni coalition of the willing to back its Yemen mission. Across the Middle East, factions deemed Iranian proxies vie with groups linked to varying extents with Saudi Arabia, a kingdom whose state Wahabist ideology has found echoes in the fundamentalism of Sunni extremist groups elsewhere.
Some argued that this toxic geopolitical mess had infected Yemen. Last week, disquieted by diplomatic negotiations over Iran’s nuclear program, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pointed to the chaos in Yemen as another sign of Iranian “aggression.” He also tweeted this cartoonish guide to Iran’s supposed “tentacles of terror.”
But the political unrest in Yemen is far too complicated to fit into a sectarian binary. First of all, it’s wrong to see the Houthis as some sort of direct Iranian proxy — using the same frame perhaps applied to the Lebanese Shiite organization Hezbollah or Iranian-sponsored militias in Iraq that are now battling the Islamic State.
[See: Yemen’s chaos, explained in one chart]
The Houthis, a political-tribal grouping whose heartland is in Yemen’s rugged northern highlands, have fought in wars for years without Iranian prompting. In the 1960s, as WorldViews discussed earlier, Houthi militias even cooperated with the Saudis in battles against an Egyptian occupying army.
Yes, many Houthis belong to the Zaydi sect, a branch of Shiism. But Zaydism is rather distinct from the “Twelver” Shiism found in Iran and parts of Iraq — a theological difference that leaves the Zaydis closer to Sunnism, as Col. Pat Lang, a former U.S. defense attache once posted in Yemen, wrote in a piece cited by the Christian Science Monitor.
“For a Zaydi to ‘convert’ to 12er Shiism is as big and alienating a step as ‘conversion’ to Sunnism,” writes Lang. “Such a change would normally lead to family, clan and tribal ostracism.”
Moreover, it’s also a matter of debate the extent to which the Houthis, whose current rebellion has roots dating back more than a decade, are operating hand-in-glove with handlers in Tehran.
They still count on considerable Sunni backing within the country and their rise in Yemen is believed to have been enabled by military units loyal to Yemen’s ousted President Ali Abdullah Saleh, a strongman who spent decades repressing Houthi political aspirations while ruling in Sanaa.
In this context, Iran is an opportunistic fringe player in what some experts say is really just a continuing tussle for power that began following Saleh’s departure in 2011 — and after a flawed political transition forced through by the Saudis and other Sunni Arab monarchies installed Hadi in office.
“There’s been a great degree of exaggeration of these ties [with Iran],” said Adam Baron, a Yemen expert with the European Council on Foreign Relations, in an interview with NPR last week. Baron elaborated:
The Houthis are glad to have Iran’s political support. They’re glad have some financial and military support. But when it comes down to it, it’s not as if the Houthis were created by Iran, and further, it’s not as if the Houthis are being controlled by Iran. This is a group that is rooted in local Yemeni issues, and its actions are fundamentally rooted in the decisions of its local Yemeni leaders.
The conflict on the ground in Yemen is very much a political one, fueled, as most conflicts are, by competing battles over turf, influence and power. But Saudi Arabia’s apparent escalation, which experts say was spurred in part by Riyadh’s paranoia about Iranian regional influence, may plunge Yemen even further into crisis.
“Seeing the specter of Iran behind all the challenges that it faces in the Middle East reduces Saudi Arabia’s capacity to make sound strategic assessments of the state of play in the region,” writes Nussaibah Younis, of the Washington-based Project on Middle East Democracy.
It’s unclear what the Saudi endgame in Yemen is. Their actions so far appear to have only exacerbated tensions in the c0untry. Air strikes have pummeled Yemen’s cities, airfields and seaports, but ground forces will be needed to consolidate any real gains in what’s already one of the Arab world’s most impoverished, yet battle-hardened states.
As my colleague Hugh Naylor reports, the Saudi air campaign has sparked a humanitarian crisis, with food stores and water supplies running low, and the few functioning remnants of the Yemeni government now also seemingly on the verge of collapse.
Apart from a collection of Arab allies, the Saudis are requesting significant military assistance from Pakistan, a Sunni-majority country with deep ties to the kingdom, but also a considerable Shiite minority that’s suffered heavily from sectarian violence in recent years. That there’s even a possibility of Pakistani troops being deployed on Yemeni soil is a sign of how dangerous a regional conflagration the crisis in Yemen threatens to become.
The implications are stark, warns Fawaz A. Gerges, professor of Middle Eastern politics at the London School of Economics.
“If Yemen descends into all-out war, which is a likely scenario, we could witness a greater humanitarian crisis than that of Syria, in terms of refugees and mass starvation,” he told The Washington Post. “You could end up with al-Qaeda being the main winner after this conflict.”
That’s hardly a scenario welcome to the Saudis, who have spent years trying to neutralize al-Qaeda’s Yemeni branch. But it is one partially of their own creation.
Related on WorldViews:
How Yemen was once Egypt’s Vietnam
What the Saudi war in Yemen means for the Middle East
Pakistan’s long history of fighting Saudi Arabia’s battles
Ishaan Tharoor writes about foreign affairs for The Washington Post. He previously was a senior editor at TIME, based first in Hong Kong and later in New York.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
The Post Recommends
How much money you need to make to be ‘middle class’ in every big city
Being middle-class often seems as American as apple pie or baseball
How Dzhokhar Tsarnaev’s immigrant path explains his guilty verdict
Masha Gessen explores the pressures that shaped Dzhokhar and his brother Tamerlan
Rob Kardashian, the most tragic figure of America’s most fame-seeking family
On Sunday night’s episode of E!’s “Keeping Up With the Kardashians,” he received what he desperately does not want: Attention.
Trending on Social Media
With violence against albinos rising, Malawi orders police to shoot ‘ruthless’ attackers
Florida woman: ‘If I’m going back to prison, I’ll at least get high before I go’
Canadian hero wants to set a world record by creating a massive mosaic of Nicolas Cage’s face
Are you running for president? Please answer these questions about the criminal justice system.
Regional memo: Hogan forces small dose of budget frugality in Annapolis
PM Update: Scattered showers tonight; Warm and potentially stormy Friday
Mentioned in this story and want to comment? Learn more
Please Sign In to Comment
Pause live updates
Jacqueline von Hettlingen
4/8/2015 1:08 PM PDT
Indeed, Iran’s role in Yemen may have been exaggerated by Saudi Arabia, which has taken a coalition of Sunni allies on board to curb Tehran’s influence in its backyard. Although the Houthis are Zaidi Shias, they represent about a third of Yemen’s population. They owe their owe their military success to domestic forces and have formed a pact with the devil, with Ali Abdullah Saleh, the deposed autocrat, who had been in power for 35 years and who had tried to beat them a few yewars. Saleh still believes he ought to return to power and that he would be the one to save Yemen from disintegrating. His clan in the army had made life difficult for his successor, installed by Saudi Arabia. For the moment the Houthis enjoy the alliance of convenience with Saleh’s supporters, Just because the Houthis are not Sunnis, the Saudis assume Iran is backing them. They feel encircled by proxies of Iran wherever they look: in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq and now Yemen.
Jacqueline von Hettlingen
4/8/2015 1:13 PM PDT
please read: to beat them a few years ago.
4/8/2015 11:57 AM PDT [Edited]
ALTHOUGH THE PEOPLE SAY THAT THE CIVIL WAR BEING FOUGHT IN YEMEN IS NOT SECTARIAN CONFLICT, THE GOLDEN TRUTH IS OTHERWISE. IT IS A PROXY WAR BETWEEN SAUDI BACKED SUNNY LEADER ABED RABBO MANSAR HADI WHILE HOUTHES, WHICH BELONG TO SHIATE SECTS, ARE BACKED AND PATRONISED BY THEHRANS THEACRATIC LEADERSHIP AS STATED WELL IN THE ABOVE ARTICLE . MOST OF THE WARS BEING FOUGHT IN MOST WEST ASIAN AND MIDDLE EASTERN COUNTRIES ARE ON THE LINES OF SUNNY AND SHIATE SECTS AND THE GOLDEN KEY TO STOP THIS SENSELESS WAR IS WITH IRAN AND SAUDI ARABIA AND NOT WITH UN AND IN THE HANDS OF BIG POWERS AND LET ONE HOPES IN THE INTEREST OF WORLD PEACE AND TO PREVENT ANOTHER-DREADFUL NUCLEAR THIRD WORLD THAT WISER COUNSEL WILL PREVAIL ON THE TWO MAJOR SECTS LEADERSHIP COUNTRIES AND HOPE POSITIVELY THEY WILL GIVE UP WAR HYSTERIA AND DO THE NEEDFUL TO SAVE THEIR OWN BRETHERN SENSELESSLY BEING BUTCHERED LIKE ANIMALS IN VARIOUS ARENAS OF SENSELESS WAR IN THE NAME OF RELEGION IN THE ABOVE COUNTRIES.MAY ALLAH WILL HELP THEM .
The Persian Dude
4/8/2015 10:13 AM PDT
Once and for all Iran has to do the Persian Gulf and greater Middle East a big — long awaited — favor by putting the Touch of Death namely “House of Saud” out of their misery.
4/8/2015 10:03 AM PDT [Edited]
So the Saudi’s are not bombing ISIS or AQAP but the author wants us to believe it’s not Shi’s vs Sunni ?
The Sunni Governments are coming in against the Shi’a rebels but it’s not a sectarian conflict ?
4/8/2015 8:43 AM PDT
Once again (the Iranian Nuclear Accord is the immediate predecessor) our intelligence is being insulted, as a very complex situation (ongoing fighting in Yemen) is reduced to a very simplistic explanation (Shia vs Sunni; proxy war between Saudi Arabia and Iran). But, this is a tried and proven template and supports current Congressional Republican opposition to the Iranian Nuclear Accord and the Republicans’ political intent to continue the isolation of Iran. Shame on the main stream media for it unwillingness to inform us about the true complexity and dynamics of the fight in Yemen. Shame on Congressional Republicans and their supporters for working against the best interests of the United States. And shame on the US public for being so gullible.
Get the WorldViews Newsletter
Free daily updates delivered just for you.